Need a slightly scary story to read aloud in October, but don’t want to seriously frighten your little listeners? The 2013 Caldecott Honor Book, Creepy Carrots! by Aaron Reynolds is the answer.
Jasper Rabbit had a passion for carrots, and liberally helped himself to the carrots in Crackenhopper Field…until they started following him. Dun, dun dun!
Readers are led to wonder whether Jasper is imagining the appearance of scowling carrots in various locations. He sees them in the mirror of his bathroom while he is brushing his teeth, but when he turns around, there are only three orange objects sitting on the bath tub ledge. Were three creepy carrots glowering at him? Or was it just an orange washcloth, rubber duck, and shampoo bottle? Each sighting is similarly vague, with a variety of orange objects providing just enough doubt that only at the end of the book do readers learn the delightful truth about the carrots.
After I read the book, students made their own creepy carrots, and had the option to take it home with them, or tape it up in the library anywhere they chose (except ON a book). If they had time, many made two–one to take home, and one to decorate the library with for the month of October. The library has creepy carrots peeking out of all the bookshelves, and the students are loving seeing them all around.
Student: “My sister made one yesterday and hung it up on in the dining room at home!”
Me: “Was it really a creepy carrot, or was it just an orange vase?”